Monday, July 7, 2025

Why should HR prioritise expertise over experience?

Must read

n a significant transformational shift, the conventional hiring landscape will soon be diverting to skills-based hiring as compared to the experience-reliant custom. Despite the valuable insights that experience offers, a paradigm shifts towards evaluating skills and expertise holds the key to building successful teams in today’s rapidly evolving business ecosystem.

The evolving nature of work: technological advancements and globalisation are constantly reshaping industries. The skillsets required for success today may be obsolete  tomorrow. Focusing on transferable skills—problem-solving, critical thinking, communication, and adaptability ensure candidates can learn and adapt to new  technologies and processes. A candidate with strong analytical skills and a willingness to  learn might outperform someone with decades of experience in a now-outdated technology stack.

Rejuvenation: Overvalued past experiences may not justify the role requirements of the present positions unless the skill sets are constantly rejuvenated with the latest trends and industry practices to keep pace. Candidates in the new roles may find it difficult to settle in the matrix of the modern organisational environment where skills determine the weight of designations. However, this translates to the need for emphasis shifting towards the skill sets than the experience solely.

Experience can be limiting: While experience demonstrates a proven track record, it can  also be a double-edged sword. Years spent in a similar role may lead to a rigid approach based on past experiences. A candidate with less experience, but possessing the right skillset, can be more open to new ideas and readily embrace change. They may bring fresh perspectives and a willingness to learn new approaches are vital for innovation and growth.

Building a diverse talent pool: Experience-based hiring often inadvertently excludes talented individuals from non-traditional backgrounds. Focusing on skills allows HR to tap into a wider talent pool, encompassing individuals who may have acquired relevant skills through self-learning, bootcamps, or unconventional career paths. This fosters a more diverse workforce which brings valuable perspectives and experiences to the table. Studies have shown that diverse teams are more innovative and achieve better results.

Objectivity and efficiency: Skills-based hiring practices rely on objective assessments such as  as skills tests, simulations, or project-based interviews. These methods provide a more accurate evaluation of a candidate’s capabilities compared to relying solely on resumes which can be subjective and prone to bias. Additionally, skills-based assessments are often quicker and more efficient, allowing HR to expedite the hiring process without compromising quality.

Building a future-proof workforce: In today’s dynamic business environment, the ability  to learn and adapt is critical. By prioritising skills and expertise, HR can build a future-proof  workforce equipped to thrive in the face of constant change. A team with strong problem-solving and critical thinking skills are better positioned to navigate unforeseen challenges and identify innovative solutions.

Finding the right balance: This is not to say that experience should be entirely disregarded.  It can still provide valuable context for a candidate’s skills. The key lies in striking the right balance. HR professionals can create an evaluation framework that assesses both experience and skills, ensuring that candidates have the necessary foundation coupled with the adaptability and expertise to succeed in the role.

Implementing the skills-based approach: Shifting towards skills-based hiring requires a  change in mindset and practices. HR professionals can undergo training to develop new evaluation methods and implement skills-based assessments. Job descriptions should be revised to focus on the required skills and expertise instead of just years of experience. Collaboration with business units is crucial to identify the specific skills needed for each role. Prioritising skills and expertise over experience offers a more effective and sustainable  approach to talent acquisition. By focusing on adaptability, diversity, and objective evaluation, HR can build high-performing teams equipped to thrive in the ever-evolving business landscape. Investing in the skills revolution is an investment in the future of your organisation. The need of the hour is sustainable business solutions that offer long-term  strategic positioning of business objectives well-aligned with the ESG global mandate. That is where the key lies. The human race is evolving with technological advancements and the dynamics are shifting rapidly. The workforce skilled to the tune definitely looks promising. bet, although the experienced clan may now step forward to mentor their predecessors in the operational excellence.  

(The author is Meenal Luther Nhür, the founder and director of Mettle Rings.)

- Advertisement -spot_img

More articles

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest article